Who Will Replace Prue Leith on Bake Off? Nigella Lawson Favourite in Judge Betting

Nigella Lawson is the strong favourite to replace Prue Leith on The Great British Bake Off after reports confirm contract talks are nearing completion. We break down the latest odds and contenders.
Who Will Replace Prue Leith on Bake Off? Nigella Lawson Favourite in Judge Betting

https://thegreatbritishbakeoff.co.uk/meet-the-class-of-2025/

Jake Ashton
Jake Ashton - Your Betting Odds Guide 👍

I break betting odds news as it happens, so you’re never left behind when the market moves or a top offer lands.

  • Prue Leith steps down from Bake Off judging panel after seven years on the show
  • Nigella Lawson is now odds-on favourite at 4/5 to join Paul Hollywood as co-judge
  • Ladbrokes market includes Nadiya Hussain, Juliet Sear, Lorraine Pascale and more

Bake Off Shake-Up: Prue Leith Departs as Nigella Lawson Nears GBBO Deal

The tent is set for a shake-up. After Prue Leith officially stepped down as a judge on The Great British Bake Off this week, reports quickly surfaced that Nigella Lawson is in advanced talks to take her place.

According to a Sun exclusive, contract negotiations are almost complete, with the celebrated TV chef and food writer expected to sign imminently. 

If confirmed, Nigella will sit alongside long-standing judge Paul Hollywood when filming for the next series begins in April.

Leith, 85, had already reduced her GBBO workload in recent years, notably stepping back from the Celebrity Bake Off spin-off and her full departure clears the way for a high-profile replacement. 

Bookmakers have responded swiftly, with Ladbrokes installing Nigella Lawson as the clear 4/5 favourite in the market to become the show’s next permanent judge.

Who Will Replace Prue Leith as GBBO Judge?

Next Bake Off JudgeOddsImplied Probability
Nigella Lawson4/555.6%
Caroline Waldegrave5/116.7%
Nadiya Hussain6/114.3%
Juliet Sear8/111.1%
Lorraine Pascale10/19.1%
Clodagh McKenna12/17.7%

Why Nigella Lawson Is the Frontrunner

With her blend of charm, culinary authority, and decades of television experience, Nigella Lawson has long been tipped as a natural fit for the Bake Off tent. 

Rumours linking her to the judging panel date back to 2024, when Prue began scaling back her appearances.

At 66, Nigella would bring energy and household-name recognition to Channel 4’s flagship baking show. 

Her extensive cookery career and loyal fanbase are seen as ideal assets for maintaining GBBO’s mainstream appeal while refreshing its lineup.

The reported progress in talks, coupled with heavy backing from punters, has pushed her odds into odds-on territory, a strong signal that an announcement could be imminent.

What the expert says...
Nigella ticks every box for Bake Off. Experience, presence, warmth, and authority. If the deal is as close as reports suggest, the 4/5 on offer might not last long.

Jake Ashton - Entertainment Betting Expert - OLBG.com

What’s Next for Bake Off?

With filming for the new GBBO series due to start in April, we’re likely just weeks away from an official confirmation. 

If Lawson’s contract is signed, it could be announced alongside the full cast of bakers and presenters.

After the show's move to Channel 4 and a shift in format in recent years, Bake Off is looking to maintain its status as a cultural institution. 

A high-profile appointment like Nigella would certainly help reinvigorate the format and draw in a wider audience.

Where to Bet on GBBO Judge Markets

While not all betting sites offer TV specials, Ladbrokes currently lead the way with a market on the next permanent GBBO judge.

To explore more entertainment markets, check out our guide to the best entertainment betting sites

You’ll also find exclusive free bets and the top-rated UK betting sites for reality TV and awards show betting.

No Comments

There are no comments here. Be the first to comment...

Please login or register to reply to this news article
KEEP READING
Who Will Replace Prue Leith on Bake Off? Nigella Lawson Favourite in Judge Betting

Who Will Replace Prue Leith on Bake Off? Nigella Lawson Favourite in Judge Betting

Nigella Lawson is the strong favourite to replace Prue Leith on The Great British Bake Off after reports confirm contract talks are nearing completion. We break down the latest odds and contenders.
Continue Reading
The Masked Singer Betting Odds: Focus Shifts to Sloth and Toastie

The Masked Singer Betting Odds: Focus Shifts to Sloth and Toastie

Colson Smith and Brenda Edwards lead the betting to be unmasked as Sloth and Toastie as The Masked Singer continues this weekend. We break down the latest odds and expert predictions.
Continue Reading
Oscars 2026 Betting Odds: Jessie Buckley and Teyana Taylor Lead Early Markets for Best Actress Categories

Oscars 2026 Betting Odds: Jessie Buckley and Teyana Taylor Lead Early Markets for Best Actress Categories

With Oscar nominations imminent, betting sites are backing Jessie Buckley and Teyana Taylor to scoop major acting awards. We look at the latest odds and expert insights ahead of the 2026 ceremony.
Continue Reading