Robert Prevost Becomes Pope: 66/1 Outsider Defies Odds to Lead Catholic Church

Cardinal Robert Prevost has been elected as the new Pope, stunning betting markets as a 66/1 outsider. See how the Conclave unfolded and what this unexpected result means for the Church.
Robert Prevost Becomes Pope: 66/1 Outsider Defies Odds to Lead Catholic Church
Jake Ashton
Jake Ashton Senior News Editor

Jake is a Football and Entertainment betting expert, with a Man City season ticket and a deep knowledge of reality TV betting angles

  • Cardinal Robert Prevost elected as the next Pope, taking over from Pope Francis.
  • The American-born cardinal was priced at 66/1 before the Conclave as a massive outsider.
  • His election stunned bettors, with favourites like Parolin and Tagle passed over.

66/1 Surprise: Robert Prevost Elected New Pope

In one of the biggest surprises in modern papal history, Cardinal Robert Prevost has been elected the new Pope, shocking betting markets where he was priced as a 66/1 outsider.

Prevost, a U.S.-born Augustinian with deep connections to Latin America and the Vatican’s Congregation for Bishops, was barely mentioned in most Conclave forecasts. 

His election represents a major shift in the expected trajectory of the Catholic Church’s leadership.

Prevost will take the name Pope Leo XIV.

What the expert says...
Robert Prevost’s election as Pope will go down as one of the biggest shocks in betting markets this year. At 66/1, he was barely mentioned but this just goes to show how unpredictable the Conclave can be. With a U.S.-born Pope now in office, expect global reaction and renewed curiosity around Catholic leadership.

Jake Ashton - Current Affairs Expert - OLBG.com

Who Is Robert Prevost?

Born in Chicago, USA, and fluent in Spanish, French, and Italian, Prevost brings a global background to the papacy. 

He served as bishop in Peru for nearly a decade before being called to Rome in 2020 to lead the powerful Dicastery for Bishops.

A moderate with a reputation for diplomacy and discretion, Prevost’s election signals a desire for unifying leadership that reflects the Church’s increasing global diversity.

Punters Left Stunned

With betting markets dominated by European and Asian favourites, very few saw Prevost’s rise coming. 

His 66/1 starting price placed him among longshots with just 1.5% implied probability of being chosen.

By contrast, names like Pietro Parolin, Luis Antonio Tagle, and Matteo Zuppi attracted most of the market attention. 

The outcome marks one of the biggest upsets in recent papal election betting history.

How the Odds Looked Pre-Conclave

CandidateOddsProbability
Pietro Parolin9/430.8%
Luis Antonio Tagle10/323.1%
Matteo Zuppi7/112.5%
Robert Sarah12/17.7%
Robert Prevost66/11.5%

Where to Bet on Church & Political Markets

Betting markets like this including Next Pope, religious leadership, and geopolitical futures are available at select betting sites

Be sure to check out the latest free bets and browse our entertainment and political betting site guide for more specials.

No Comments

There are no comments here. Be the first to comment...

Please login or register to reply to this news article
KEEP READING
2025 Nobel Peace Prize Betting Odds: Donald Trump Tops Peace Prize Betting Market as Speculation Grows

2025 Nobel Peace Prize Betting Odds: Donald Trump Tops Peace Prize Betting Market as Speculation Grows

Donald Trump leads 2025 Nobel Peace Prize odds at 13/2 after reports he helped prevent nuclear conflict between India and Pakistan. See the full market and expert analysis.
Continue Reading
Next General Election Odds: Reform UK Overtake Tories in Most Seats Betting Market

Next General Election Odds: Reform UK Overtake Tories in Most Seats Betting Market

Reform UK have leapfrogged the Conservatives into second place in the betting to win the most seats at the next UK General Election, with Labour holding on as favourites.
Continue Reading
Next Labour Leader Odds: Wes Streeting Leads Market Despite Burnham's Polling Surge

Next Labour Leader Odds: Wes Streeting Leads Market Despite Burnham's Polling Surge

Wes Streeting is 9/2 favourite to succeed Keir Starmer, but LabourList polls show Andy Burnham leading in grassroots support. Starmer's exit not expected soon as Labour enjoy governing power.
Continue Reading